my daughter is 7 going on 8 and her elementary school has recommended that we take her to see a therapist. The guidance councilor says she believes my daughter has O.D.D. (opositional defiance disorder). the school even called a family counciling center they work with & got the ball rolling for us. now i'm working with the in-take specialist to get the appointment set up. my question is this: what do i tell my daughter that won't scare her? this scares *me* and i'm terrified of telling her something that's going to scare her. obviously, i want to be as honest as possible, but my husband and i disagree on the when and hows. he says we shouldn't tell her anything & just take her & do it & just keep it all very low key. but i don't like that idea. i want to give her a good reason for it, i want her to be informed. has any one else out there gone through this? any suggestions?
posted by:
bats
Massachusetts
  • Well, My 1st question is do YOU think your daughter has ODD. I think that ODD is the new ADD. Everyone is getting a diagnosis by the schools of one or the other.

    I'd be pretty pissed that the school went ahead without my consent and contacted a family councelling center.

    All that said, when my parents took me to a therapist when they were getting divorced (I was 8) they told me that they had someone they wanted me to talk to. I wasn't in trouble he just wanted to talk to me, and they thought it would be a good idea of I did.
  • I agree with you bats,- its weird to ask your child to just walk into a strangers place and "visit", without telling what for or why you are there.

    I was asked to go to do "maths" tutoring when my parents got divorced. I loved going, especially since we often put the maths aside and did interesting things like draw each member of my family as an animal.. and such. I loved the trust I had with the tutor, and shared openly with him..- only to find out later that he told all to my mom,- and in fact it was all a lie, and he was actually my psychotherapist. it ruined my trust in any therapist, and I felt betrayed and lied to by all. Not really the lesson or help I was supposd to get.

    I have an Aspergers Syndrom daughter, who has also dyslexia and other labels.. I always tried to see the teachers need to label as a way to find help,- and humour them if they saw it as some kind of big deal. I trusted that my daughter is fine,- with or without label, and I always told her that she was just different,- and different is cool and desireable actually. I told her that the therapy is there for her.. therapists arent gods, they are human and may get things wrong too, but it was worth a shot to try and glean a deeper understanding of oneself. Take it all with a pinch of salt,-

    for you bats, I want to give to you that your daughter is fine,- she will be alright!- actually most of the big achievers are oddballs and didnt fit the standard mold, and that it can be a good sign if she is not just "normal". You need to come to terms with this "diagnosis", realise that it is just an aid for teachers and carers to understand certain behaviours and it is not all and the sum of who your daughter is. It is her environment trying to understand and deal with her particular character.
    I'd keep an eye on the "experts", dont let them be the ones having the last word,- but listen to their views and tips,- they just might come in handy here and there... :-)
    Dont worry!- and if you manage to stay cool, then your daughter will too, I'm sure.
    • I see this a little differently. I believe a child will look to see how a parent really feels about something before reacting. Like when my daughter was learning to walk, and would fall, I'd always say very cheerfully, good try, let's keep going.
      A therapist is a very educated person to talk to. Not much more or less. What's so scary about that, for either one of you? Nothing wrong with putting it, like, "Well, I know school isn't always easy, this is a person that may be able to help things go more smoothly for you."
      Yes, absolutely tell her the truth. Absolutely do not attach a fearful value judgment to it.
  • i just want to say thank you all for your advise. i truly appreciate it. i told my daughter this morning. i told her that on thursday her, mommy & daddy were going to the city & talk to Gwen. i told her that i know she's not happy about getting sent to the principals office & getting in trouble all the time so Gwen is going to help the 3 of us come up with some good ideas on how we can all work together to help her out. she got a little nervous & asked me what the visit would ential. i told her that it would largely be all of us talking together & that she could tell Gwen what she's thinking and feeling. she asked if we were doing this because she was in trouble. i told her that this isn't a punishment & she's not in trouble, but it's to help her so she gets in less trouble in the future. then she asked if she could tell Gwen anything & if she would get in trouble for telling Gwen the things that she's done (that got her in trouble in school) & i told her of course not. she relaxed a little bit. but i'm sure more questions will come as the week progresses. i just really emphasised that this isn't a punishment & she was ok with that. so thank you so much everyone! i really am very grateful for the support!
    • Thank you for this post, I think this is the situation into which we are headed w/my 13 yr old. I wish some one in elementary school had come to the conclusion that we needed to test him.
      He's very smart, gifted even and at this age is quite affronted by being tested for "special education" I kinda think he may also be trying to avoid classes that will actually challenge him, my hope is for a more "hands on" educational environment for him.
      While I can see ODD being misused, i feel it may be quite accurate for my teen. You've given me some ideas on how to cope w/this situation and w/my teen.

      Thank you and Namaste,
      E
      • your welcome & i'm very grateful to have other parents on tribe share their input. we've been taking her to therapy regularly now & she actually really enjoys it. she loves the therapist & understands why she's going & that it's to work toward the goal of improving her life. (and the lives of her parents too!) it hasn't solved anything yet, but we're kind of in a holding pattern right now unfortunately. the therapist & my husband & myself have all agreed to put her on a trial of meds. however, my daughters current doctor is a pain in the a**. he doesn't believe add/adhd/odd exist. he doesn't think they are real & tells us there's nothing wrong with her when we've taken her in to be examined. HE does't have to do home work with her. HE doesn't have to sit through teacher conference after conference & get the phone calls at work about what she's done wrong at school. HE doesn't have to actually LIVE with her. the doc. has point blank refused to perscribe meds & told us that if we insist on moving forward with it, then we'd have to take her to a nurologist. happily i just got a new job with amazing benefits so as soon as i get my new health care info we're changing doctors.

        basically so far the therapist has at least reinforced what we say to our daughter at home & that's helped us to feel less insane & i feel better just knowing we're at least working towards a goal. best of luck to you & yours!
        • I'm sorry you're having a rough time w/your doc, though I also understand his point of view given the unrealistic view of educators as to what kind of control children should be able to maintain, and realistically the brighter they are the moree aware/engaged in their environment they are and school adminstrators tend to try to use diagnoses coupled w/meds to chemically restrain children.

          It's when it hits extremes and you can't do anything with them that it seems the diagnoses are accurate and DO exist. Though I also wonder how much of it is reactive behavior and not actual chemical issues.

          It blows me away to see parents going the full length to ensure that their children prosper, and then there's parents giving little girls sugar to amp them up for beauty pagents and making them wear prosthetic teeth and fake tans, and of course the ones in the grocery store berating their children for being... children. *sigh* All we can do is try to do the best we can for our children and hope that others see our example. Keep on keepin' on mamma!
          • >and realistically the brighter they are the more aware/engaged in their environment they are and school adminstrators tend to try to use diagnoses coupled w/meds to chemically restrain children. <

            I'll second that..! Actually I am quite pleased that some Doc's haven't sold out to the pressure by the drug companies, and will stem against this tide of drugs as a cure all.

            I dont know your daughter, nor do I live with her,- but as an independent observer I would definitely try all other options first, before applying these kind of psycho-interfering drugs.
            I have seen cute little"hyper" kids turn into sleepless, neurotic and drug dependant teenagers.. who have far more serious problems(neurosis/obsessions) in my humble opinion because of continued drug taking throughout the childs developmental years..

            I have a limited experience of taking psycho-interfering drugs.. and was amazed at how much is affected, other than the targeted symptoms.. and will never take any again, unless I am in real serious trouble..

            We know so little about how hormones influence our development,- but Do know that they are responsible for development and management of very deep seated and basic functions.. it seems dangerous to trust a drug that has been commercially developed and has limited studies available on possible side effects..

            If it were me, I'd use drugs (unless herbal or homeopathic etc) only as a last resort. Too many drugs have been pushed as safe by drug companies and bribed officials,- only to be taken off the market 20 years later because the negative effects were empirically proven. (i.e. enough people had to suffer the consequences...)

            I wish you luck with your quest, and hope you have well informed and conciencious people advising you. ;-)
  • Just thought I would add some personal observation which may be helpful. I read a study recently that children with ADD were found to have eased symptoms when out in nature. Check out these articles for reference:

    www.americanforests.org/produc...ves.php

    dnr.wi.gov/org/caer/ce/...82205ner1.htm

    I've also noticed with my little one drastic changes in behavior depending on whether he's indoors or outdoors. People who have also looked after him noted his defiant behavior decreases 90% when he's playing outside.

    I personally believe many children simply aren't meant to be cooped up in a classroom, and sitting at that, for 6 hours a day, 5 days a week. Then get sent home to sit even longer to do homework. If this seems to resonate with you regarding your daughter, maybe she could be helped by finding a school for her which involves a lot of outdoor time... like a farming and horticulture program. I know there's a Waldorf school in the Bay Area that has this type of focus...don't know where you live but it might be worth checking out if any such thing is available in your area.
    • The same notion occured to me a few years ago, when I realized I functioned so well without meds when I was camping, working festivals. I think it's about the higher oxygen content in the air, being around grass and trees and nature. . .makes the blood flow better in the body and brain.
      Is ADD less common in rural areas, or perhaps, just less diagnosed?
      • macrobiotics will explain this as the "grounding" I touched on earlier. Basically it can be summed up as being "in touch (literally) with nature". It will raise the flow of Chi (life energy) in a Yang fashion. ADD is a state of too much Yin, so gentle grounding will help. This will be literally touching soil, grass,- and as you said, fresh air..

        laying on a lawn, playing in water, sitting in or under a tree, all these things will be gentle Yang activities, and should help some ADD symptoms.

        Both my kids love going outside in a stormy rain, running around,- which seems to discharge some excess Yin as well.

        (But take care not to get too much sun, as this can have the reverse effect..)

        In answer to you question sooz: my guess would be that it really is less common in rural areas, if real outdoor life is experienced. I know studies have been made as afr as allergies go, and they are proven to be far less common in farming type environments.
    • i agree totally! in fact we just moved for that reason. where we were living before had no where for our daughter to play outside. so we went from a really nice apartment in a crummy neighborhood to a really crummy apartment in a nice neighborhood. there are tons of other kids her age & as long as the weathers nice she'll stay outside all day long. and the change has been dramatic. without meds. she *wants* to be outside with her "girlfriends". she runs around & rides her bike & rollerskates and is happier than she's ever been. it's kind of difficult for us because the apartment is not what we are accustomed to, but it's SO much better for her. thank you for the links!
      • oh bats, what a relief! Well done!- The more I am hearing and finding out about ADD, and/or medication, I get more and more horrified, and this seems a very natural way to solve the problem.

        I hope you will feel the relief it gives you and you also can be comfortable in your new home!
        • well i'm new but thought i'd jump right in here since i've been in a somewhat similar situation.

          when i left my battering husband, my lawyer suggested i take the kids to the therapist. i was in social work grad school at the time so i had some good friends in the field. it was not pleasant since the expert therapist did not have a feminist bone in her body and knew nothing about any progressive therapy. so next time i would choose a MUCH different kind of therapy.

          but what i told my kids was: there are doctors for all kinds of things: there are doctors for feet, and doctors for broken arms, and doctors for teeth and there are even doctors for feelings. i explained that sometimes kids in divorce and violence had lots of painful feelings or just strong feelings and that the doctor was there to help with that. and to provide a safe place to talk about stuff.

          that seemed to help though they still hated it. if i had it to do over, i'd find a feminist therapist FIRST and foremost, and i think it would have been a MUCH better experience.

          all in all though, i'm glad i accessed the mental health system for my kids.

          fyi: i work for an environmental justice coalition and i know add and autism and other labels, disorders, and diagnoses have been on the rise during the same time that more toxins and pollutants have poisoned our environment. i'm wondering if there's a connection and there are new studies that show there is a connection between autism and toxins.

          good luck; you sound like a great mom. i do think honesty is the best policy with kids because they are going to figure it out eventually and you don't want them to feel betrayed by a lie.

          hope all goes well for you and your daughter!
          • thank you Kinnari! i've heard that enviornmental pollution as well as possibly vaccinations are a large contributor to these labels. add/adhd is something that runs in my family, i have it as well as my dad & his sister & i have a sneaking suspicion my grandfather has it too. ever see an 80 year old man wtih adhd? it's not for the faint of heart that's for sure! but i do think that pollutants & chemicals make it worse that it would be otherwise. i also think it's exaserbated by the amount of preservatives, sugar, fat and junk that's in food today.

            i'm *very* anal about what we eat. to the point that i left a really cheap babysitter because she wouldn't feed my daughter the lunches i sent along with her. she said she wanted every child to eat the same thing so it was 'fair' then proceeded to feed my daughter junk and wondered why she misbehaved. we eat about 80% organic food & humane, chemical free dairy products. we buy eggs from local farms that are run by people we know. and we are largely meat free. my daughter likes meat so i let her eat it if she wants it when we're out, but it's not something i have in the house. i keep her sugar content very low because she has a really bad reaction to it. most kids will get wound up & wild for a bit. she gets horribly cranky, angry, defiant and depressed. it's the strangest thing. so yeah, i'm the mom in the grocery store thats reading every label.

            and there is a dramatic difference in her behavior from when she eats natural sugar free food and when her grandparents give her fast food. but we're still working on it & keeping our fingers crossed.
  • today my daughter starts taking Adderall. her behavior was ok after the move for a while, but it's been escalating to the point where she got kicked out of her daycare. this is th 3rd one she's been kicked out of.

    her therapist recomended meds as did her doctor. so we're starting by treating the adhd symptoms. however the doctor says that this is just the beginning, and if the meds work, then they will treat *just* the adhd. she thinks my daughter might be bi-polar or have oposisitional defiance disorder, and if that's the case then she's going to refer us to a specialist. so this begins the trial and error phase.

    has anyone else had any experience with Adderall?
    • I only know a few things about a few anti-depressants, not Adderall. Did they recommend a behavioral therapist at all? Someone to work with her one-on-one? Maybe the medication could be just a temporary thing if a behavioral therapist steps in to help... I have a good friend in this field & I'll ask her opinion next time I see her...
      • yes, the doctor told me that if adderall doesn't work then we would be refered to a pediatric behaviorist specialist. the doctor doesn't seem to think this will be the answers to all the problems & i feel like we're basically waiting for it to not work so we can move on.
        • The adderal may work. There's also a diet used for ADHD children that has been successful. . . a little googling ought to find it. It removes a lot of chemicals from the diet, it's low in sugar but high in fat which seems weird, but it forces the body to burn its fuel slowly, which (I way over-simply) helps to control the behavior.
          good luck.
          • bats: kicked out of 3 different day cares?! Phew, thats rough.

            What were their grounds?- It so upsets me, that the so called specialist daycarers (you dont get this service for free, right?) have so little tolerance, or are so little prepared to adjust to a more intense child..

            I mean, if she were on crutches, they would make arrangements for her, right?!

            Anyway, my rant probably doesnt help you one bit.- I hope you can find a reasonable level of satisfaction with her development, and treatments,-
            As you say, trial and error,- keep on your toes, if you dont like what you hear go and get second, third opinions.. and do what your instincts tell you.
            Best wishes, Jana

Recent topics in "Feminist Counterculture Motherhood"